The question
When a company launches a new product, opens another location or buys a business, the same question comes up: do we call it what we call everything else, or give it its own name? The answer isn't a matter of taste. It decides how much each brand costs to build, how much reputation they lend each other, and how much damage a mistake does.
That decision is brand architecture: the structure of a portfolio that defines each brand's role and how it relates to the others. David Aaker and Erich Joachimsthaler organized it in 2000 into a tool that is still the reference: the brand relationship spectrum. It isn't two options, it's a spectrum. To decide in practice, we reduce it to three models.
1. Monolithic: one brand for everything
Everything lives under the same name, with descriptors: "Brand + what it does". Aaker and Joachimsthaler call it a branded house and use Virgin as the example.
- For: every dollar of investment builds a single brand; launching something new costs less because it arrives with borrowed reputation.
- Against: everything shares one fate. A stumble in one line splashes the rest, and it's hard to stretch the brand toward a very different audience or price.
- Works when: the promise is the same across everything you do.
2. Endorsed: own brands backed by the parent
Each product has its own name, but the parent brand appears as a guarantee: "Product, by Brand". Courtyard by Marriott is the classic example of this model.
- For: the new brand can have its own personality and still arrive with the parent's credibility.
- Against: you manage two levels and need clear rules for how much weight each one carries.
- Works when: the product needs to stand apart, but trust in the company is what closes the sale.
3. Independent: a house of brands
Each brand stands alone and the corporate name barely shows. This is the house of brands; Aaker and Joachimsthaler cite Procter & Gamble, which then operated more than 80 brands. In Mexico, Grupo Bimbo works this way with Bimbo, Marinela and Tía Rosa.
- For: each brand can own its segment without getting in the others' way, and a problem stays contained.
- Against: each brand is built from scratch, with its own budget.
- Works when: audiences, prices or promises are so different that putting them together would confuse.
A case that shows it can change
In August 2015 Google announced it would reorganize under a new holding company, Alphabet. Google became one subsidiary among several, and the projects furthest from its core business began operating separately. Architecture isn't forever: it adjusts when the business changes.
Five questions to decide
- Is the promise the same across the whole portfolio?
- Do you speak to one audience, or to audiences that shouldn't cross?
- If one line has a problem, how much can it drag down the rest?
- Do you have the budget to build several brands at once?
- Do you plan to sell, merge or spin off any business in the coming years?
If most answers point to "the same", think monolithic. If they point to "different", independent. The rest is usually solved with an endorsed brand.
Sources
At IIHB, every architecture project starts with a map of the current portfolio and where the business is heading. Is your company about to launch, buy or spin off something? Write to us: hola@2hb.com.mx
- Aaker, D. A. & Joachimsthaler, E. (2000). "The Brand Relationship Spectrum: The Key to the Brand Architecture Challenge." California Management Review, 42(4), 8–23.
- Aaker, D. A. & Joachimsthaler, E. (2000). Brand Leadership. Free Press.
- Page, L. (Aug 10, 2015). "G is for Google." Google.
- Google Inc. (Aug 10, 2015). Form 8-K, U.S. SEC.

